One resident. One question. Motion denied. Case continues.
Our Story.
This challenge started at my back fence. It is now before a court of law. Here is why.
In the words of
Steve
Ventura County Resident · 3.5 Years Seeking Accountability on SOAR
My name is Steve. The prime farmland immediately behind my home is the proposed site of the Ventura Ranch Farmworker Housing Project — PL23-0051. For more than three and a half years, I have been asking a simple question through public comments, correspondence, records requests, public hearings, and ultimately through a writ proceeding: what adopted authority supports the Ventura Ranch approval pathway reflected in the public record? Materials reviewed to date have not identified the authority that answers that question, and that is why this effort continues.
SOAR — the Save Open-space and Agricultural Resources ordinance — was passed by Ventura County voters to protect prime farmland from permanent urbanization. SOAR requires voter approval for most changes involving protected Agricultural, Open Space, and Rural lands. A central question in this case is whether the public record identifies the adopted authority that made the Ventura Ranch approval pathway available under SOAR.
I have spent thousands of dollars and an enormous amount of time pursuing this through legitimate channels: public comment, Public Records Act requests, and attendance at nearly every meeting held on this project. I produced materials, organized outreach, and raised concerns about public health, site suitability, and fire danger — all documented, all on the record. Those concerns were acknowledged procedurally and set aside substantively. That pattern repeated itself at every stage of the process, and it is part of what led me to the authority question at the center of this case.
A Note About This Website
This website is not an accusation. It is not intended to allege wrongdoing by Ventura Ranch Partners, LLC, County staff, County Counsel, elected officials, or any other participant in the approval process.
The purpose of this website is to document the public record, explain why I became involved, and identify questions that I believe remain unresolved in the materials reviewed to date. Reasonable people can disagree about what those documents mean. Ultimately, those questions are for the courts and the public record to resolve.
The Process
How the Process Unfolded
In the early stages of this project, county staff indicated that a full Environmental Impact Report would be required. The county ultimately pursued a streamlined review process. The administrative record reflects the environmental review pathway that was followed and the public comment that was submitted at each stage.
The administrative record documents how the review process developed from initial application through final approval. I raised concerns through public comment and correspondence at each stage, and those submissions are part of the record.
I have requested every map, every adopted document, and every record the Planning Department has on file related to this site and its SOAR status. I was told directly by the Planning Department that no other map exists — that what I had been given represents the entirety of what has ever been adopted. I went through all of it. The authority chain connecting the NVAA's Open Space/Agriculture designation to the ECU-Agricultural approval pathway used for this project is not in those records. I have never stopped looking.
Source Document
North Ventura Avenue Area Plan — Figure NV-6
This figure from the adopted Area Plan carries the same adoption date as Figure A-3 — yet designates the project site as Agricultural only. Figure A-3 carries a revision date of December 17, 2024. Figure NV-6 does not. The materials reviewed to date do not identify the adopted action associated with the A-3 revision, the purpose of the revision, or which figure reflects the lawfully adopted designation at the time the County acted.
Document withheld from public posting to protect privacy. Available as part of the court record.
Both maps are part of the public record. The 1997 General Plan map shows the site designated Agriculture/Open Space at the time SOAR was created. Figure A-3 of the Area Plan carries a revision date of December 17, 2024 — after the Ventura Ranch application was already in process. Neither map contains an Existing Community designation at this site. The materials reviewed to date do not identify the adopted action associated with that revision, the purpose of the revision, or how the revised figure relates to the approval pathway relied upon by the County.
"The authority chain connecting the NVAA's Open Space/Agriculture designation to the ECU-Agricultural approval pathway used for this project has not been identified in the materials reviewed to date. I have not stopped looking."
Over time, the issue stopped being about a project behind my house. It became a question about whether voter-adopted land-use protections continue to mean what they say.
In my view
A 5–0 Vote. With Authority Questions Still Unresolved.
The Ventura County Board of Supervisors approved PL23-0051 by a vote of 5–0. In my view, the SOAR authority pathway was material to a lawful approval — and the record does not reflect how that question was resolved before the vote was taken.
The Public Records Act documents obtained through formal request contain communications related to the project approval process. Those documents are part of the public record and are referenced in my filings.
From my perspective, the public comment process was constrained. Speaking time was reduced. Substantive objections were entered into the record and, in my observation, set aside without meaningful response. When the hearing concluded, the most critical element was still absent from the record: the adopted legal authority pathway that would permit development of SOAR-protected land without a public vote. The materials reviewed to date have not identified that pathway.
The Question That Started It All
What adopted public authority placed this land into the ECU-Agricultural / Existing Community pathway — and where is that authority in the record?
Why This Case Was Filed
The Planning Commission approved Ventura Ranch on February 19, 2026, by a 3-2 vote.
After reviewing the approval record available at that time, I expected to find the adopted authority supporting the project's approval pathway. The materials I reviewed did not identify the authority I was looking for.
Shortly thereafter, I filed this writ proceeding seeking judicial review of that question:
What adopted authority supports the Ventura Ranch approval pathway, and where is it identified in the public record?
That question existed before the later Board hearing and remains the central issue of this case.
Legal Basis
This case was filed as a traditional writ proceeding under Code of Civil Procedure § 1085, challenging Respondents' authority to deem complete, process, and approve Ventura Ranch, Project No. PL23-0051. The Court's writ case-management order expressly recognizes that this proceeding may involve CCP §§ 1085, 1094.5, and 1102 et seq.
Why I Am Still Standing Here
For more than three and a half years, I have pursued this challenge — not because I oppose progress, housing, or opportunities for others, but because I believed the promises that were made.
When we bought our home, we were told that the farmland and open space behind us were protected — that SOAR existed for a reason, and that as long as the voters continued to extend those protections, that land would remain safeguarded from urban development. We relied on those representations when making one of the biggest financial and personal decisions of our lives. We built our future around them. My wife, our dogs, our cats, and a parrot who has strong opinions about all of it — we built our lives here with the understanding that the voters' commitment to preserving agricultural land was real, enforceable, and worthy of public trust.
Now, after years of hearings, studies, legal filings, and countless hours devoted to understanding this proposal, I find myself confronting the reality that the very protections the public repeatedly voted to preserve are being asked to yield without a clear showing of the adopted authority that makes that lawful.
I will be the first to admit that when this issue first arose, my reaction was personal — because this is not some abstract project occurring somewhere else. It is literally in my backyard. My initial instinct was to focus on how it might affect my immediate community, and I openly voiced those concerns.
But as I spent more time examining the larger issues at stake, I came to recognize that responsible planning cannot be driven solely by whose backyard happens to be closest. I recognize that some will dismiss my concerns as NIMBYism. The truth is that my proximity gives me every reason to care deeply — but my opposition is rooted in something far larger than self-interest. If voter-approved land-use protections can be set aside whenever they become inconvenient, then no neighborhood, no open space, and no public promise is truly secure. Insisting on lawful, documented decision-making protects everyone — including the people who will live and work here.
I am not opposing farmworker housing. I support safe, affordable housing for farmworkers — the people who would live here deserve that, and so does every worker in this county. My challenge is not to them. It is to the County's legal process.
What I am asking for is straightforward: if the County relied on an Existing Community designation to avoid SOAR and Area Plan protections, the public deserves to see the specific resolution, map amendment, or voter-approved action that made that possible.
That document should exist. It should be in the record. The materials reviewed to date have not identified it.
This challenge has never been easy. It has consumed evenings, weekends, and years that can never be returned. Yet I continue because this is about more than the view from my backyard. It is about whether citizens can rely on what their government tells them, and whether voter-adopted protections still mean what they say. Transparent process is not a barrier to good outcomes. It is the foundation of them.
"This challenge has become about preserving trust itself — and that is why, after three and a half years, I am still standing here."
The Community Behind This
None of this has been done alone. Over the past three and a half years, I have had the privilege of hearing from neighbors along Bounds Road, homeowners throughout Valley Vista, and people across Ventura who care just as deeply about this land as I do. Their presence at hearings, their willingness to speak up, and their shared commitment to getting this right carried this effort through the moments when it felt impossible to continue. I am grateful for every one of them.
In Memory
Doug Shumpert
Valley Vista neighborhood resident and homeowner for many decades. A beloved friend. Rest in peace.
Doug was my next door neighbor and my closest friend. He had lived in the Valley Vista neighborhood for many decades — a homeowner, a constant presence, and a beloved member of this community long before this project ever appeared on a planning agenda. His home sat directly adjacent to mine, both of us looking out at the same SOAR-protected land that this project would consume. He did not need to read a map to understand what was at stake. He could see it every day, the same way I could.
When AMCAL held its community outreach meeting in the earliest days of this project, Doug and I had planned to attend together. I went to pick him up that evening and found him on his kitchen floor. He had suffered a stroke. I stayed with him until the ambulance arrived, then proceeded to the meeting alone. At that meeting, community members submitted questions and concerns. The questions were collected. I did not observe substantive responses to them at that session. Doug passed away shortly after.
But his commitment to this land never wavered. Not once. Not even at the end. His belief in what SOAR was created to protect — agricultural land, open space, the voters' right to decide — was unwavering until his last day.
Doug and I made the NoVenturaRanch t-shirts available together. Seeing those shirts worn throughout the neighborhood and beyond — by people who understood what was at stake — was his vision as much as mine. A community saying, together, that this matters.
Rest in peace, Doug Shumpert. Your vision of land preservation — especially on the SOAR-protected property we shared as neighbors — lives on in every page of this record.
To everyone who has been part of this — thank you. From the bottom of my heart.
Steve B.
Ventura County Resident · Neighbor
Please Stand With Us
This has been an all-consuming effort for years — financially, personally, and in terms of time. My family and I are fighting to preserve the beautiful prime farmland immediately behind our home from being permanently removed from Ventura County's agricultural roster. Once that land is paved, it does not come back. If you believe that elected officials must answer to the law they are sworn to uphold — and to the voters who put them in office — we are asking for your support.
See How You Can Help